Secrets for the Best Personal Defense Cartridge

Image of defensive tools

Left to right: full metal jacket round, traditional hollow point, and more modern personal-defense round with polymer tip.

Each piece of equipment we use for personal defense is a tool. And as with all tools, we have to consider the design and purpose of the tool and ensure we are putting it to the proper use to be effective. It’s possible to dig a hole with a claw hammer, but it’s not the most effective or efficient method. A shovel can put a nail in a board, but it’s not the best way to do it.

A handgun cartridge was designed to do one thing, but not what most people think. The term “knock-down” power is the most misleading term in personal defense. There is no handgun cartridge with the capability to “knock down” a man. I also submit to you that no handgun bullet in history was ever designed to knock a man down.

Throughout history, there have been two primary types of weapons: Impact weapons and cutting weapons.

Impact weapons are designed to hit the target with sufficient focused energy to destroy the target or stop the target from moving. A large-scale example is the MOAB, or Mother Of All Bombs. The MOAB uses explosive energy alone, with no shrapnel, to destroy targets.

image of wadcutter round

Wadcutter round used to cut smooth round holes in paper targets during competition shooting.

A smaller scale is the use of bean-bag munitions by law enforcement. Bean-bag rounds are designed to impact and stun the suspect so the suspect stops aggressive action. These and other impact munitions like rubber and wood bullets are designed to impact the suspect. They are not designed to penetrate the organs and cut the person. They are specifically designed NOT to cut or penetrate the target.

Cutting weapons are designed to do just that, cut. Pointed sticks, spears and swords evolved into firearms. Bullets are designed to cut the opponent, pierce organs and disrupt the central nervous system. The invention of gunpowder gave distance and range to the spear in the form of the bullet. While the technology of the delivery system changed, the target (the human body) remained the same.

There are two primary methods to stop or kill a mammal, and men are mammals: Disrupt the central nervous system and cause massive blood loss.

The first is the most difficult. The total disruption of the central nervous system by destroying the medulla oblongata will cause complete shutdown of the target. This requires placing a shot at the base of the brain that penetrates the skull and destroys the “apricot.” This is extremely difficult to do with a handgun cartridge. The brain bucket has been designed to protect that most important organ and it does a pretty good job.

image of personal protection short barrel

This cartridge is specifically designed for short-barreled revolvers like my Smith & Wesson 340 PD.

The second and most common way to kill a mammal is to cause massive blood loss. This is a slow process and the animal can still be active during it. Every deer hunter has seen or heard of a perfect shot on a deer that took out the heart and lungs, and yet the deer still ran for many yards before it collapsed. Deer are similar to men in size and organ placement.

A man who is not quickly stopped is still a danger. Many men, “good guys” and “bad guys,” have been shot but continued returning fire and attacking. The FBI Miami Shootout is an example of men, good and bad, who were shot but continued to fight.

Ultimately the bullet has to penetrate and cut the target to cause central nervous system disruption or blood loss. Penetration is something that is rarely discussed in self-defense circles, but I believe it is a key element for proper cartridge design.

image of basic components of a pistol cartridge

Basic components of a pistol cartridge are the bullet, case, powder, and primer.

Cartridge Design

A firearms cartridge consists of the bullet (projectile), case, powder, and primer. A good personal-defense cartridge must optimize all of these elements. Penetration is a crucial element in the cutting power of any handgun cartridge.

Bullet considerations include:

Caliber or diameter of the bullet
Bullet weight
Bullet design

Many discussions have been had about the best caliber for self-defense handguns. I will summarize them by saying it is a personal decision based on your needs and abilities.

Image of .25 auto round 35 grain bullet

.25 auto round only has a 35-grain bullet and minimal velocity. I do not recommend this cartridge for personal defense.

Tom Givens, owner of RangeMaster Training, sums up the need for accuracy first. He says, “A good hit with a marginal bullet is better than a marginal hit with a good bullet.”

Tom also touches on the fact that a bullet is a cutting weapon: “Calibers smaller than .38 Special/9mm do not penetrate enough to reach truly vital structures deep within the body. Once the threshold of adequate penetration is reached, bigger caliber bullets seem to offer two advantages:

  • More likely to break a bone than to glance off it;
  • Larger diameter wound track, bleeds more profusely/quickly. Which carries more water in the same amount of time, a garden hose or a fire hose?”
Image of .38 super cartridge

Be sure what you are buying. The .38 Super cartridge is for a semi-auto handgun, not the .38 revolver many people think of when they hear “.38.”

Bullet weight is another issue. Many calibers have several bullet weights to choose from in standard loads. The type of weapon you carry and the cartridge load itself all affect the success of the cartridge.

Bullet design is a key element. There are many choices for modern hollow-point self-defense ammunition. Some ammunition companies are very effective at advertising. I strongly suggest investigating the manufacturer and type of ammunition carried by law enforcement. LE agencies spend a great amount of time, effort and money to determine the best carry cartridge. The work they have done may be beneficial to you and save you time and money as well.

Having said that, how do you find out what ammunition law enforcement agencies are carrying? There is no central collection point of information. The easiest way is to ask your friendly neighborhood cop. Preface the conversation by letting the officer know you are a legally armed citizen or CCW permit holder. Tell him you are looking for a good personal defense round and ask if he has any suggestions. He may suggest what the PD carries or he may have other suggestions that might be better for you. Remember what I said about some ammunition manufacturers being very good at advertising.

Calling local training academies could get you some useful information as well. Just be sure to tell them why you’re asking. LEOs face many dangers and are always on guard for bad guys trying to collect intelligence information on equipment and tactics.

Search the Internet. Unfortunately, there are many unsecured law enforcement forums. A simple Google search of “law enforcement duty ammunition” can show discussions about this topic. Just be aware that the information on these forums may not be real or accurate, just like anything else in the cyber world. I don’t mind giving that suggestion because the bad guys already know it.

As with any product you buy, perform due diligence. Is the company a reputable manufacturer that has been in business for a long time? Check online for information about the product. Is this a solid and proven design or is it a new “miracle” ammunition?

image of 9mm full metal jacket

9mm full metal jacket round and new polymer tip hollow-point round also in 9mm.

Whatever you carry, choose a proven design of hollow-point bullet. The hollow-point design expands and makes a larger wound channel, increasing the cutting power of the bullet. The full metal jacket (FMJ) bullet is great for practice but not appropriate for personal defense. I am also not impressed with multiple-projectile or shot-shell cartridges. I have tested them extensively and find they do not have sufficient velocity for penetration.

As shooters, we are responsible for all rounds we send downrange, and many of these multiple-projectile and shot-shell cartridges cause an unacceptable spread in the pattern. I love shotguns for personal defense, but they were not designed to be used out of pistols with rifled barrels.

box of 90 grain bullets

This 90-grain bullet in a .380 personal defense round leaves the muzzle at 1000 feet per second. Compare that to a 9mm or other calibers.

Powder

The powder load directly impacts the velocity of the bullet. I believe that velocity is the key element not discussed in self-defense circles. For years we have heard that the 9mm is better than a .380, and yet the bullet is very similar in size and weight. The significant difference is the velocity of the bullet.

I strongly urge shooters to carry +P loads for any firearms that are rated for that cartridge. The +P is a cross between a standard cartridge load and a magnum load. It gives increased projectile velocity and better cutting power and penetration. Be sure to check that your firearm is rated for a +P load before you use it in that firearm.

image of powr ball box with .380 bullets

Another manufacturer makes a .380 with a slightly lighter bullet with increased velocity.

Check the firearm itself, especially revolvers, and look for the cartridge rating. Check your owner’s manual for +P rating for other firearms. Generally speaking, older firearms are not rated for +P ammunition.

There is +P+ ammunition available. This ammunition is generally used for pistol-caliber carbines, specifically machine guns. I strongly recommend you do not use +P+ ammunition in any firearm unless you are certain that the firearm is rated specifically for +P+ ammunition. Be certain your firearm is rated for whatever ammunition you use.

box of .45 barrel 230 grain bullets

Here’s the big-daddy, the flying ashtray. This .45 leaves the barrel slowly but has a big 230-grain bullet. And this is a +P!

Hand Loading Ammunition

I do not recommend hand loading self-defense ammunition. There are many liability concerns should you have to use the ammunition in self-defense. Modern manufacturing techniques are so good that buying ammunition from a manufacturer is a much better choice.

The case and primer need to be good quality and properly sealed. Ammunition for self-defense is carried in all sorts of weather and conditions. The modern commercial techniques are proven.

Image of 124 grain bullets

This 9mm round leaves the muzzle at 1220 feet per second and has a 124-grain bullet. The increased bullet weight and muzzle velocity make the 9mm more effective in personal defense than a .380 handgun.

Ammunition Maintenance

Hopefully you are going to the range on a regular basis. Check your expensive carry ammunition as you load and unload at the range. The oils in your skin can cause corrosion over time. Look for damage to the cartridges. Check the bullet and ensure it is properly seated to the case. Watch for anything out of the ordinary and replace any damaged ammunition.

Ammunition is a perishable commodity. It will lose effectiveness over time with exposure to heat and cold, snow and rain, and human hands. Consider rotating your carry ammunition. I trade out my carry ammunition every year at my birthday. It’s an easy date to remember, and I shoot it to give myself exposure to the carry load and a little birthday present.

The firearm you spend so much money on to buy and train with is absolutely useless without effective ammunition. Spend a few dollars more and get the best ammunition to keep yourself and the people you love safe.

Categories: All Articles, Defensive Firearms, and Handguns.

Tags: ammo, ammunition, cartridge, handgun ammunition, pdn, personal defense, personal defense network, and pistol cartridge.

49 Responses to “Secrets for the Best Personal Defense Cartridge”

  1. Robert J. Mayor says:

    This is the kind of info. I enjoy reading about.
    Keep it coming.

    1. rick cornell says:

      I m must agree 100% with you….this is good reading w/lots of need to know information !!!! :-)

  2. Cecilio says:

    Great article. It touches several points that are too often ignored. Plain but important. Simple but necessary.

  3. Ron Willis says:

    Great article. I am a retired police officer with over 30 years of service and former military and police firearms instructor. One thing to be mindful of when asking your local police officer about ammo is, not all police officers are “gun guys/gals.” Some receive their new rotation of ammo on the annual range day, load their weapon and forget about it. Many would be unable to tell you the brand name, bullet weight and configuration of what they carry.

  4. Court Bowman says:

    Great and thought provoking article.

    One point I think I may take a different point of view on. You say there are two ways to kill a mammal: disrupt the central nervous system and cause massive blood loss.

    I’ve always thought of it more like a car. For an internal combustion engine to work it takes fire fuel and air. I think mammals are the same way. You can kill one by depriving it of the central nervous system, the circulatory system (blood loss or the heart which pumps), or the respiratory system. Respiratory system can be taken out through the intake (airway) or lungs.

    Maybe not a significant departure from your presentation in regards to small (or large) arms fire, but my 2c for what it’s worth.

  5. DavidWilliams says:

    Special thanks to Vandalia Tactical for the ammunition used in the photographs!

  6. DavidWilliams says:

    @Court Bowman-You point out another good way to dscribe it. Some instructors I know use the example of cars. They refer to the “hydraulics” which is the the blood and the “electical systems” which is the brain and nervous system. All these are good examples to make the point. Thanks to all for reading and commenting. I really appreciate the input!

  7. RRStubbs says:

    When I was in combat and shot at, I always layed down a spray of bullets 1/4 of a clip for the purpose of getting the targets head down. Then I moved away from where I was last visible by the target. Then I carefully moved into a position where I could get a clear shot at where the target was going to play peek a boo. With 1 round or 2 at the most I was able to place a shot into the head at or about the eye socket. I can’t carry a M-16 around town. So I have opted for a Keltec PMR-30. Yes it is a low caliber weapon with a high speed bullet. I can squeeze of 10 rounds and have 20 rounds left over for the kill. What do you think?

  8. Ernie says:

    I liked what all you said plus what the comments that were made too! I have 3 carry pistols. 1 a pocket size 9mm. 2. a mid size 40 cal. & 3. A mid size 45 cal. all with JHP in them. I hope I never have to use any of them on a human life. I try to shoot at targets both still & moving when I can. I use up the old ammo to do so. In cold weather I can put my 9mm in my coat pocket & you would never know I was carrying a pistol. Being Left handed I have trouble finding a good holster to use. Thanks to PDN for all you do.

  9. Loyde Williams says:

    Very helpfull info. Question: depending on normal conditions what is the shelf life for hand load ammo.? I have some as far back as 1994,stored in out doors shed,varying temps. Thanks.

  10. Lou Lavender says:

    Very good article. I’m prior military, and had 31 years on the job as a law enforcement officer. Now a senior citizen, I qualify every year through my former police dept. I shoot a .44mag for my revolver, and a Springfiled Arms .45 XD for my auto pistol qualification. I DO have a .380, but only carry that on an ankle holster in the summer, when light clothing must be worn.

  11. Jim Greene says:

    Rob Pincus has changed his recommendation for the best defensive caliber. Before he favored the 40 S&W in a semi auto but now believes the 9mm Luger is a better choice for most people. He sites larger magazine capacity and easier to place multiple rounds on target in a stressful defensive encounter.

  12. J. E. Perry says:

    Good information. Keep it coming!

  13. Clathrus says:

    “A good hit with a marginal bullet is better than a marginal hit with a good bullet.” This is certainly true, but a marginal hit with a good bullet is better than a marginal hit with a marginal bullet. Guess which kinds of hits most people will make? Readers of this article except of course.

  14. JPKirkpatrick says:

    Good article, shakes the cob-webs loose in the brain and makes you think!

    Loyde Williams – If your ammo has been in a none controlled temperature and levels of humidity, it may not be too reliable, especially for 17 years!

    Now, I have some hand loaded ammo that is 30 years old and performs just fine, but is stored in a temperature and humidity controlled environment. Variables like temperature and primers/bullets that are not sealed (like Military Ammo is) will become unreliable; it could be weaker or more potent, you never know! Get a bullet puller and reload them again, with fresh primers too!

  15. Dave Denney says:

    Good article Dave. Especially like the explanation of what a bullet is. This is good for the newby to know and it defintrly is just one tool of the toolbox of self defense. Sometimes a tactical retreat is the best move if you don’t have the gear to get the job done. Well Done. Dave Denney

  16. GrayLion says:

    Hi There ! Just curious if there’s something I don’t know, or if its already been tried. I’ve seen bottleneck handgun cartridges before, I even own one, (.357 Herrett)but one I’ve been curious about is whether a cartridge basically made of a .45 ACP necked down for a .40 projectile has ever been tried. I know the full power 10 mm cartridge probably already owns that part of bullet weight/velocity/energy spectrum, but I I just thought it made too much sense for it not to have been tried. Thanks for any info.

  17. pimaine says:

    Great article. Goes great with ‘Bullet of the Month Club’ also. Both are a must read and now I won’t feel bad once a year shooting my self defense ammo at over $1/round. It’ll be my Christmas present.

  18. remy says:

    Take a look at the 400 Corbon. Basically a .45 necked down to .40…

    I was a cop for some time before I decided I like engineering better. I carried a 9mm on duty and always felt under-gunned. I now carry a .45 and don’t worry about bullet performance if I ever had to use it. Just my 2 cents.

  19. Anetrard says:

    I am sure you will love designer knockoff bags QuVdSWgR [URL=http://www.fake--designer-handbags.net/]knockoff designer purses[/URL] to your friends XqqhzQLh http://www.fake–designer-handbags.net/

  20. Ulcenlew says:

    check this link, burberry outlet store tbkHsIHR [URL=http://www.burberryoutlet-online2013.org/]burberry us[/URL] for more detail nbRLbAND http://www.burberryoutlet-online2013.org/

  21. Inontife says:

    check this link, discount gucci seILcytZ [URL=http://www.replica-gucci.webs.com/]cheap gucci bags[/URL] , for special offer vlYwUbzM http://www.replica-gucci.webs.com/

  22. JBJohnson says:

    Very good discussion concerning the practicalities of the real world with respect to a bad hit with a good billet and vice versa. Consider that many of you can probably put lots of rounds very close together time after time in the light of day on a range, but how about at night in a dark room when you’re awakened from a dead sleep with someone coming at you. I tell friends of mine who ask for advice on home defense weapons…In the awakened-from-a-dead-sleep scenario, I’m bound to hit the intruder in the shoulder or the ass, or somewhere in between….that said, I’d rather misplace the shoot in any of those locations with a 230 grain .45 JHP than a 130 grain 9MM FMJ…refer back to the previous discussions of cutting force, impact energy, expansion, and using the right tool for the job. Keep up the great discussions. Molon Labe

  23. JEBaltes says:

    I have 3 different handguns that I use for ccw. I feel confident in my ability with any of them. My snubbie is loaded with 135 gr +P GDHP’s; I fully trust those, 1911 has 230 gr Winchester PDX1′s, and my 9mm is filled with 124 gr Remington Golden Sabers. I am quite sure any of them will do the job.

  24. BetsNews says:

    Wonderful put up, very informative. I wonder why the opposite specialists of this sector don’t realize this. You should continue your writing. I’m sure, you’ve a huge readers’ base already!|What’s Going down i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I have found It positively helpful and it has aided me out loads. I am hoping to give a contribution & help different users like its aided me. Great job.

  25. vanboy says:

    Inside the event that some people remain obstinate doubt the talent of George A. Romero soon after its passage 1968 “Night on the Dwelling Dead” e book, we current “The Crazies”! Yet again a thin film full critique of society as well as black humor. “The Crazies” forthwith request your attention to your series of pre-opening credits and powerful high level of excitement is maintained all the way through the whole movie. The modest city of Evans City, Pennsylvania is topped which has a secret, but quite fatal virus, leaving the governing administration mad or lifeless infected incurable. “Trixie” was originally developed as being a chemical weapon, not a scientific or military leaders understand how to close when innocent people are exposed. The preparation straightforward plot and economic are well camouflaged by Romero eye for detail. From your beginning, he built a tense atmosphere of mass hysteria pretty realistic confuses you? the viewer? not knowing wherever the characters are infected and which aren’t. It might merely trigger-Pennsylvanian mountain for all we know! Even however the film hardly ever becomes truly “disturbing”, there are quite a number of scenes that shock and sense strangely true. It is possible to also established “The Crazies” was far ahead of his time, for example chemical warfare is substantially more during the image of what it absolutely was 30 years ago when the film was shot. Romero principle is very simple but effective: the failure and greed of mankind is far a lot more frightening than any horror monster could ever be. The best example is the army becomes mysterious and menacing in their white suits icky.

  26. It can be nearly close to impossible to come across well-updated visitors on this niche, then again you look like you fully understand the things that you’re writing on! Excellent

  27. Ed says:

    But wanna input on few general things, The website pattern is perfect, the written content is really
    excellent. “All movements go too far.” by Bertrand Russell.

  28. What’s up to every body, it’s my first visit
    of this weblog; this blog contains amazing and in fact
    good material for readers.

  29. e3 9100 005h says:

    You need to take part in a contest for one of the finest blogs on
    the net. I am going to highly recommend this website!

  30. seo packages says:

    How come so many SEO workers come from India?
    They are the most common experts I find
    I have added you in my weekly website list, keep up the good posts

  31. Hi there mates, its impressive post on the topic of tutoringand completely explained, keep it up all the
    time.

  32. In simple terms, the identical basic Sonic story told differently yet again. That
    said, where some have complained that Sonic feels not quick
    enough even if running inside the Wii U version, here about the 3DS he still
    feels a tad too fast at both speeds. Eggman has built six villains known as the Deadly Six.

  33. Admiring the commitment you put into your site and detailed information you present.
    It’s good to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the
    same unwanted rehashed material. Great read! I’ve bookmarked your site
    and I’m adding your RSS feeds to my Google
    account.

  34. How these two parts distribute the stress between them is going to be the only things that are not rigidly folded, are not ordered, until the assembly copmes together.
    So, no more explanation you can do an experiment that
    has to be some role that glycans play. We determine the damage of the structure if you
    would like more information on. Nucleus: The nucleus is a membrane enclosed organelle which is found in many fruits
    and vegetables.

  35. Some weapons offer superior firepower through high rate of fire (ROF).
    Its not clear to me whether the high cost of premium
    ammo would be sufficiently offset by the higher
    WR gained by using it. In that case get the suspension upgrade and then return to the normal tech path.

  36. Quality articles or reviews is the main to attract the people to pay a visit the site, that’s what this website
    is providing.

  37. May I just say what a comfort to discover somebody that actually understands what they
    are talking about on the web. You definitely know how to bring a problem to light and
    make it important. More and more people must look at this and understand
    this side of the story. I was surprised you
    aren’t more popular given that you definitely have the gift.

  38. Remarkable! Its in fact awesome article, I have got much clear idea
    on the topic of from this piece of writing.

  39. porn app says:

    Hi friends, fastidious post and good urging
    commented here, I am in fact enjoying by these.

  40. technology says:

    I’m not certain where you are getting your information,
    however reat topic. I needs to spend some time studying much more or understanding more.
    Than you for magnificent information I was on the lookout for
    this information for my mission.

  41. Winnie says:

    Quite frankly, contrary to popular belief, making money
    online isn’t as hard or difficult as most folks make it out to be
    and once you understand and implement what is often called the ‘power
    of duplication’, then anyone – regardless of age,
    sex, education or technical background can start making money just as
    fast. Stop wondering how to make quick money online and start making it happen today.

    Information on how to start a blog and make money should be useful.

  42. Laurie says:

    It’s impressive that you arre getting thoughts from this post as well as from ouur argument made here.

  43. Howdy I am so happy I found your website, I really found you by error, while I
    was looking on Digg for something else, Nonetheless I am here now and would just like to say thank you
    for a remarkable post and a all round interesting blog
    (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to read through
    it all at the moment but I have saved it and also added in your RSS feeds, so when I have time I
    will be back to read much more, Please do keep
    up the superb work.

  44. Your instructor works together with you so that you
    can find the questions combined with the solutions by
    yourself, not merely for the process also for all your lifestyle situations.
    Talk to my web page link and find out additional info
    about Millionaire Strategies Revealed. A statistical evaluation was utilized
    to produce these outcomes — a deep psychological user profile was accomplished on hundreds of top carrying out sales representatives along with their final results in contrast.

  45. Enable our cause. My buddy was just identified as having this.
    We would like to express our help and support!

  46. Hannelore says:

    Hello very nice blog!! Guy .. Beautiful .. Wonderful ..
    I’ll bookmark your site and take the feeds additionally?
    I am glad to find numerous useful info right here within the post, we need
    develop more strategies in this regard, thanks for sharing.

    . . . . .

  47. Actually no matter if someone doesn’t know then its up to other viewers that they will
    assist, so here it happens.

  48. lifehack says:

    This is really interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger.

    I’ve joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your
    wonderful post. Also, I’ve shared your web site in my social networks!

Leave a Reply

  • (will not be published)