Students come to defensive training courses to learn how to lead a safer life and, although training accidents are always a possibility, no one wants to be injured when training. As a result, the instructor needs to take their job very seriously.
Unfortunately, many people don’t really understand safety as a concept and sometimes this important concept isn’t applied when it most needs to be. That is the case in this video. Watch it.
It is understandable that people might immediately want to comment on the unsafe actions of the student in this situation. There is no doubt that the student violated at least one important gun safety rule. We all need to know and understand the fundamentals of gun safety and apply that knowledge every time we handle a gun. If you have any questions on the topic of gun safety, please take a few minutes to read this detailed article on gun safety I have posted at Safety Solutions Academy.
SAFETY IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE INSTRUCTOR
In the video, the student’s actions (as incorrect as they are) are not what bother me the most. Instead it is the actions of the instructor that have me concerned. Remember, safety is the responsibility of the instructor. Before any training exercise begins (I use that term generally, not necessarily in reference to this video), it is the duty of the instructor to determine if the benefits they believe the students will gain from the exercise are worth the risks involved. There are always risks. From a twisted ankle to a gunshot wound, risks are always there. The question is, are the benefits worth taking the risks?
An experienced instructor who considers safety wisely looks at it from multiple angles.
- What are the gains that the student will take away?
- If a risk becomes reality, how severe will the consequences be?
- How likely are the risks to actually happen based on the circumstances?
All kinds of factors can come into play, especially with regard to that last question, the likelihood of the risks. The chances that something will happen are constantly changing depending on the conditions that exist on the range and within the students who are participating in the exercise.
A training activity where the benefits significantly outweigh the risks with an experienced group of students on a sunny day might not pass the test with the same group of students in cold and rainy conditions. In the same vein, perfect conditions and a group of students who lack confidence and experience could spell disaster. More capable students might have no trouble with the activity in more difficult circumstances. It isn’t easy to make these decisions, but it is important.
THE RESULTS OF MULTIPLE SAFETY ISSUES
Let’s take a look at the reasons for the serious safety issues in this video and the ways they could have been averted. Before the ND, it is clear that a safety violation of some kind is likely to happen. The student’s hips and shoulders aren’t square to the target. A safe draw can certainly be accomplished when you aren’t squared up to your target, but most people need to be taught to draw safely in this type of orientation.
This is an error on the instructor’s part. Failing to teach your student the techniques required to safely perform a task is asking for trouble. This isn’t a time to assume your students know what to do and how to do it. A quality instructor assesses the skill level of the student before asking the student to perform tasks that have additional risks associated with them.
The student, who is intending to establish a two-handed grip, negligently fires the gun before the weak hand meets the strong hand. This is a clear indication that the finger was on the trigger before the student was prepared to shoot. This is a violation of fundamental gun safety rules. My guess is, this was not the first time his trigger finger was placed on the trigger before the decision to shoot was made. This is an error on the instructor’s part for not appropriately addressing this important issue prior to this situation.
It is an additional failure to commence a complex drill when your student has a fundamental safety issue. When asked to execute multiple tasks simultaneously, students who have a history of making safety errors can be expected to make additional safety errors. It is irresponsible to allow a student to participate in a drill they are unlikely to complete safely.
I saved the best for last.
After the negligent discharge (and multiple negligent instructor decisions related to safety), the student is not only allowed to continue the drill, but encouraged to do so. The instructor can be heard saying, “You’re good, you’re good!” just after the errant report. This is most disturbing and at the same time sums it all up.
This student at this moment is anything but good.
At a minimum, the student is negligent for firing his gun when he did not intend to fire the gun, but the situation could be much worse than that. You can clearly see the student’s surprise and confusion. The last thing this instructor should have this student do, now with a certain history of safety issues, is continue with the “training.” The confusion, anxiety, and other emotions this student is now experiencing are not going to enhance the student’s ability to complete the drill safely. This third and most irresponsible failure again rests firmly on the instructor.
SAFETY ISSUES IN THE DEFENSIVE TRAINING WORLD
This video is a clear example of several issues that can be seen all too often in the defensive firearms industry. Instructors fail to understand the gravity of their role when it comes to safety. Safety is the responsibility of the instructor. Instructors need to understand what safety really is and know how to make decisions about where to take their students next in training. As this video shows, some aren’t up to the task.
An instructor isn’t paid to coddle students and make them feel good. The instructor’s jobs are to help the students grow and to maintain a safe learning environment. Telling students, “You’re good, you’re good!” when they aren’t is an “everybody wins” participation trophy, a “keep the customer happy” approach, and it has no place in the firearms training world.
When students violate safety rules, the instructor’s jobs are first to ensure safety and second to instruct. Before a student can continue with training following a safety violation, there must be instruction on what the error was, why the error was a safety concern, and steps the student must take to keep the training environment balanced so the benefits of training significantly outweigh the risks. Dismissing an error or dismissing a student without vital re-teaching is a disservice to the student and the safety of the general public.
The professional defensive firearms instructor has the responsibility to make a go/no go decision when it comes to the safety of the training regimen during a defensive gun class. The decisions the instructor makes need to be based on the totality of the circumstances and the concept of safety. These decisions should not be based on convenience, the drill that the sheet of paper says comes next, or the feelings of the customer.
If you are a firearms instructor, it is your duty to know how to prevent safety issues through quality instructional decisions and how and when to deal with safety violations when they can’t be prevented. Instructors, rise to the responsibility.
If you are a student, you must demand your instructors take the lead when it comes to safety in firearms courses. Students, expect professional firearms instructors to tackle the issue of safety head on, and hold them responsible when they do not.