Usable Power for Personal Defense: Part 2

training knives

Blunted training knives that replicate your EDC knife provide better returns on your lethal force training simulations. Photo: author

In Part 1, we examined how physical fitness training and handgun and ammo selection should be geared toward personal defense preparedness if that is your goal, as opposed to just indulging a hobby. Now let’s look at some other considerations for anyone who’s serious about personal defense.

Gear Upgrades

The most important upgrade you can make is to the human weapon system. The first tools to be purchased should be selected based on their usefulness to improve the system. Training, ammo, and range and mat time are at the top of the list. The following upgrades come next.

Laser Dry-Fire Pistol Replicas

The Shot Indicating Resetting Trigger (SIRT) Pistol is an example of a laser dry-fire replica and is a tool for dry-fire corrective trigger control training. It provides an optional light that activates when the trigger begins to move. This provides visual feedback of muzzle deviation during this phase of the trigger press. A secondary light activates when the trigger is fully pressed to the rear, indicating any muzzle deviation during the follow through.

SIRT Pistol

Any surface area can be used to monitor the laser dot feedback. Simply visualize your pre-determined target area, and you can monitor trigger control utilizing both sighted and kinesthetic aim. Photo: author

Sighted Aim: Sighted aim with laser dry-fire pistol replicas provides feedback of your trigger control while improving how you align your sights over your sight picture.

Kinesthetic Aim: New shooters often have difficult consistently aligning the muzzle in and parallel with the line of sight. Laser dry-fire pistol replicas provides valuable ammo-saving feedback with how you are mechanically aligning the pistol to your line of sight, thus improving your kinesthetic alignment while also improving trigger control.

Contextual Laser Dry-Fire Drills

These provide greater returns on your invested dry-fire training. How much trigger control you need is determined by the precision demands of the target, and once muzzle deviation consistently remains within the thresholds of target limitations, contextual conditions should be immediately integrated into the practice. Examples of contextual laser dry-fire replica drills are:

unorthodox shooting positions
Presentation from the holster and unorthodox shooting positions include shooting from seated positions, which reflects circumstances such as shooting from inside a vehicle. Photo: author
one handed shooting
One-handed shooting is likely to occur if you need to shoot while on the phone with 911. Photo: author

Clearing the Stimulus-Response Conundrum of Laser Dry-Fire Replica Training

Non-Diagnostic Linear Malfunction Clearing is the most efficient method of clearing malfunctions and is contingent on stimulus-response automation. Laser dry-fire replicas may not have a rackable slide, and provide a click stimulus. While it may seem that laser dry-fire training may contradict the NDLMC stimulus-response model, it should be noted that the stimulus in NDLMC is more specifically click after intended live-fire actuation. Thus, laser dry-fire training poses an insignificant risk of erroneous reflex in NDLMC automation because we are cognitively aware a laser replica dry-fire tool is not a live-fire pistol. Furthermore, NDLMC may be integrated into laser dry-fire replica practice with positive results and with insignificant risk of negatively affecting the reflexive pattern. Lastly, recoil is psychologically disruptive to trigger control. As such, laser dry-fire training should not be a measure to evaluate trigger control, but strictly a visual feedback tool to identify and correct erroneous mechanics.

Blowback Airsoft Pistol

The Blowback Airsoft Pistol is a low-cost alternative to Simunition tools and is a more accessible resource for everyday citizens to train with. While the Blowback Airsoft Pistol fails in trigger control benefits, the slide actuation provides pistol handling and manipulation benefits that tools like blue guns cannot.

blowback airsoft pistol 1blowback airsoft pistol 2blowback airsoft pistol 3
Shooting from a compressed position poses the risk of inducing malfunction from clothing interfering with slide function. Risk is inhibited by indexing the magazine base on the body while orienting the muzzle to the target. Close quarter defense training with a cleared firearm provides weapon access and pistol handling benefits, but feedback of slide position is limited to a third-person observer. Blowback Airsoft Pistol provides an affordable alternative and allows the slide to actuate, providing feedback of pistol position and operation. Photos: Rob Pincus
rackable slide
Rackable slide also provides benefit of simulating an induced malfunction caused by firing a round while the slide is being grabbed. This affords the opportunity to practice clearing the malfunction once retention of the weapon is achieved and there a window of opportunity to do so exists. Photo: author
critical incident reload
Blowback Airsoft Pistol also affords the opportunity to improve Critical Incident Reload when training close quarter techniques. Photo: author

Emergency Driving Dynamics

One of the most overlooked personal defense skills is emergency driving dynamics. Getting your driver’s license teaches you how to obey road laws. It doesn’t teach you how to drive! This is the equivalent of getting your California Handgun Safety Certificate and assuming that owning and operating a gun with no training are enough to prepare you for a lethal force encounter!

emergency driving dynamics

Photo: author

It is critical to learn how to quickly evade danger and quickly arrive at a trauma center. Driving your vehicle solely on throttle mashing for top speed leads to over-driving, where the linear momentum of your vehicle over-powers the ability for directional change. Quickness is the result of managing the upper limits of traction by way of steering, brake, and throttle inputs relative to vehicular feedback.

Most (though not all) driving classes are exclusive to law enforcement or security drivers, leaving drag racing, track driving, and auto-cross as available resources to the general public. If we measure public racing paradigms for relevance to emergency driving dynamics, we can define which hobby better mirrors training.

Drag racing is irrelevant. Track driving may have some usefulness, but the higher track speeds are rarely seen on public roads. Auto-cross is the most technical course, with speed and cornering demands more closely reflecting the smaller windows of reaction time found on public roads. Auto-cross can teach you how to slalom out of a road-rage brake check, recognize how throttle and steering inputs push the limits of traction, and how to efficiently negotiate turns for optimal quickness.

evasive driving

Robert Stangarone is a Sports Car Club of America Auto-Cross champion, and he super-charged his automatic-transmission Scion FR-S tuned for auto-cross and daily driven car applications. Photo: author

Some auto-crossers are passionate about tuning but new to driving. Before upgrading the car, it is critical to upgrade the driver. Leaving the suspension soft enough to induce recognizable yaw and weight transfer is critical for the driving student to develop a sense of when to brake, steer, and throttle. Stiffening the car’s suspension will provide much less feedback, which may be recognizable by seasoned drivers but is rarely discernible to new drivers.

scion frs

Minimally modded Scion FR-S provides enough feedback for improving driver reflex. Photo: author

In choosing a training method for lethal force encounters, we need to understand critical incident dynamics as a whole, including stress physiology, circumstantial variability, psycho-motor skill development, and more. Simply buying big guns and going to the range are the equivalent of buying a muscle car and racing the quarter mile. It might perform well in isolation, but it won’t help you be a better driver, and the car would be nearly useless in any other context.

The topics discussed here and in Part 1 are just a few examples of what should be taken into consideration when distinguishing a hobby from training. Before rushing out and purchasing upgrades, upgrade the end-user. Distinguish which hobbies you enjoy, and which enjoyable hobbies mirror training. Choose your training method with respect to context, and tune the human weapon system for usable power.

Discussion
  • (will not be published)

4 Responses to “Usable Power for Personal Defense: Part 2”
  1. Dr. KJ

    How does the dry fire laser translate to your own individual weapon? The H&K VP9 has a longer trigger pull than the Glock 17/19/26. what type of weapons are availalble?

    Reply
    • CST

      Thank you for your comment. A good alternative to the SIRT pistol mentioned in the article, is LaserLyte Laser Trainer Pistol Cartridges. The LaserLyte Laser Trainer Pistol Cartridges allow you to train with your defensive pistol without any ammunition cost or the need to go to the range. Laser Trainer Pistol Cartridges are simply inserted into the chamber of your pistol and will then produce a laser dot on your target every time you press the trigger. Here is a link to the full video: http://www.personaldefensenetwork.com/video/004592_laserlyte-laser-trainer-pistol-cartridges/

      Reply
    • ROBERT

      I like the SIRT guns the best, but they are extremely costly. Look for the “Blue guns.” LaserLyte makes or handles lots of them. I found one IDENTICAL to my carry gun and you can also get them with lasers and laser reactive targets for practice.

      Reply
  2. John M. Buol Jr.

    Yes, competitive auto-cross is great way to learn car handling for defensive driving as the skills cross over nicely.

    Benchrest shooting is irrelevant. Conventional shooting (bullseye) has some usefulness, but the higher precision is rarely seen real world. Practical shooting is the most technical course, with speed and cornering demands more closely reflecting the smaller windows of reaction time found on the street.

    Practical shooting can teach you how to move efficiently, recognize how target/sight focus and trigger inputs push the balance of speed and precision, and how to efficiently negotiate for optimal quickness.

    Reply